Amagansett: A Travel Guide to A Hamptons Gem

A Year-Round Travel Guide to Amagansett, NY

Tucked between the bustle of East Hampton and the wild beauty of Montauk, Amagansett is a low-key coastal town that manages to feel both timeless and fresh in every season. Whether you’re packing beach towels in July or layering up for a crisp fall walk in November, Amagansett is pure East End magic. Here’s how to make the most of a weekend here — any time of year.

MORNING RITUALS

Start your day with a coffee from Jack’s Stir Brew — a staple for locals and early risers, open bright and early. Grab a warm almond croissant or a breakfast sandwich and stroll to the dunes for a peaceful oceanfront start.

In cooler months, take your coffee to Atlantic Avenue Beach or the boardwalk near Indian Wells, where the only sounds are waves and wind.

WHERE TO SHOP

Amagansett has quietly fantastic shopping, with a blend of thoughtful curation and local flavor.

• Ulla Johnson is your go-to for breezy dresses in summer, rich textures and layers in winter — a year-round dream closet.

• Pink Chicken is the sweet spot for seasonal dresses and beachy outfits for the littles.

• Love Adorned offers unique jewelry, textiles, and beautiful objects that make perfect gifts (or souvenirs).

• Amber Waves Farm Store is more than a farm stand — it’s a full seasonal market offering organic produce, local wines, fresh bread, flowers, and picnic provisions.

FAMILY FUN & SEASONAL EVENTS

• In spring, the egg hunt at Amagansett Square is a can’t-miss for families — it’s wholesome, adorable, and perfectly small-town.

• In summer, the square turns into a community hub with live music, food pop-ups, and a little lawn perfect for picnics or dancing barefoot.

• In fall, head to Amber Waves for pumpkin picking and farm tours.

• In winter, enjoy quiet beach walks and wood-fired dinners — Amagansett becomes a peaceful, windswept retreat.

BEST BEACHES

• Indian Wells Beach: Ideal for families with calm water and soft sand — less crowded than others.

• Ditch Plains Beach (nearby in Montauk): Surfer heaven with dramatic cliffs and nearby food trucks in warmer months.

• Atlantic Avenue Beach: Classic East End spot, lifeguards in summer, and great off-season for long walks.

For nature lovers, nearby Napeague State Park offers uncrowded dunes and hiking trails — perfect for a little solitude any time of year.

WHERE TO EAT — AMAGANSETT’S BEST RESTAURANTS

Breakfast & Casual Lunch

• Carissa’s The Bakery (Amagansett): Rustic, upscale bakery with fresh bread, seasonal salads, and warm pastries. Perfect for takeout picnics or cozy indoor bites.

• Felice’s: Tiny and charming, this is the secret spot for fresh smoothies, grain bowls, and a quick breakfast after yoga or a beach walk.

• Amber Waves Café: Seasonal, farm-fresh offerings with a view of the fields — ideal for lunch with kids or coffee with a book.

Lunch or Low-Key Dinner

• Doubles: This newish gem blends laid-back vibes with upscale touches — great for a casual meal with inventive twists on comfort food.

• Coche Comedor: A vibrant Mexican restaurant right off Main Street — sit at the bar for mezcal cocktails and order the fish tacos or wood-fired shrimp.

Dinner & Date Night

• Il Buco al Mare: A sister restaurant to NYC’s Il Buco, this spot serves Mediterranean-inspired seafood and pastas in a beautifully minimalist setting. Dreamy for a summer evening or cozy fall dinner.

• Meeting House: A warm, inviting American bistro with rotating seasonal menus — think roasted local fish, autumn squash, and perfect cocktails.

• Rowdy Hall (relocated from East Hampton): Now in Amagansett, this cult-favorite gastropub is great for elevated burgers, beer, and a rainy night out.

Seafood Staples

• Stuart’s Seafood Market: Grab a fresh lobster roll or takeout feast of steamed clams, corn, and wine from next door at Amber Waves. Perfect for an easy backyard dinner at your Airbnb.

• Lobster Roll (a.k.a. Lunch): Technically in Napeague, but iconic enough to mention — especially fun with kids or for a casual midday bite on the way to Montauk.

WHERE TO STAY

Skip the hotels and book a wood-shingled Airbnb — ideally one with an outdoor shower for summer or a fireplace for cozy winter nights. Amagansett is filled with quiet lanes, ocean breezes, and houses that feel like they’ve been waiting just for you.

MAKE IT YOURS

Whether you’re in town for beach days, farm dinners, or windblown winter hikes, Amagansett welcomes you with a quiet kind of charm — the kind that makes you breathe a little deeper and slow your pace. It’s not just a summer spot; it’s a place to return to again and again.