The Best Hotels in Montauk (2026): Where to Stay
Montauk is at the end of the road, and that geography explains the hotels. There is no sprawl here and very little room to build, so what exists is a small, strange mix: one big oceanfront resort, a restored 1920s yacht club on its own island, a handful of motels that were reinvented as design hotels in the last fifteen years, and a couple of places that are really restaurants and music venues that happen to have rooms upstairs.
The other thing to know before you compare a single photograph is which water you want. Montauk has an ocean side and a harbor side, and they are entirely different trips. The ocean side is surf, dunes, and the Atlantic doing what the Atlantic does, which is loud and cold and beautiful. The harbor side, around Lake Montauk and Star Island, is calm water, boats, and sunsets. Families with small children are usually happier on the harbor. Surfers and anyone who came for the beach should be on the ocean.
Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa
The only full-service oceanfront resort in Montauk and the default answer for anyone who wants everything in one place. Gurney's sits on roughly two thousand feet of private beach on the Old Montauk Highway, with the ocean directly below the rooms and a seawater spa that draws filtered Atlantic water into indoor pools, which is unusual in the United States. It's also the only property here that stays properly open year round.
There are multiple restaurants, bars, a beach club, and fire pits on the sand, which means you can arrive on a Friday and not move the car until Sunday. For a lot of people that is the entire point of Montauk.
The honest caveat: The commonly raised issues are the price relative to the room finish, the scale and crowding in peak season, and the beach club filling with non-guests.
Best for: Full-service stays, winter weekends, anyone who wants to park once.
Montauk Yacht Club
Maybe the most interesting property in Montauk and the one most visitors overlook, because it's on Star Island in the harbor rather than on the ocean. Built in 1928, it reopened after a multimillion-dollar renovation and now runs across 35 acres with 107 rooms, under Proper Hospitality.
The marina is the largest in the Hamptons, with more than two hundred slips taking everything from day boats to superyachts, and the whole property is organized around that. There are two pools, one adults-only and one for families on the Great Lawn, a private beach, tennis, bocce, sand volleyball, and the first padel courts in Montauk. Electric Mokes run guests into town or out to the surf breaks, and bikes are free. Ocean Club Montauk is the restaurant, built around a raw bar and braai-style grilling with what the property claims is the largest open kitchen in the Hamptons.
The honest caveat: this is harbor water, not ocean. If you pictured surf and dunes you will be disappointed, and the ocean beaches are a drive or a Moke ride away.
Best for: Families, boats, groups, anyone who wants space and facilities.
Marram
The design pick, and the best value of the properties actually on the ocean. Marram sits above the beach near South Edison with a low-slung, stripped-back look that reads more Malibu than Hamptons. Rooms come in four bands, and the difference matters more here than at most hotels: beachfront and ocean view face the Atlantic, courtyard faces the dune-scape, and dune rooms face the parking lot. Book by category, not by price.
Communal fire pits run in the evenings with complimentary s'mores, which is a small thing that families consistently rate highly.
The honest caveat: the rooms are deliberately minimal and some guests find that tips into under-equipped, with limited storage and hanging space. The food is counter service rather than a restaurant, and it backs up badly at breakfast and lunch in peak season. In July and August the property gets crowded enough that the calm the design promises is hard to find.
Best for: Couples, design-led stays, families who want the ocean without resort pricing.
Hotel Corduroy
The newest arrival, open since May 2026. Blue Flag Capital took the former Sunset Montauk and reworked it with Ward + Gray into 29 rooms built around Montauk's surf culture, with private guest access to Sunset Beach nearby.
It's the same ownership behind the Sag Harbor redevelopment, which suggests the standard is serious rather than a light refresh.
Best for: Surf trips, design, travelers who want the new thing.
Barlume Beach
The other 2026 opening, and a different proposition. Nineteen rooms overlooking Montauk Harbor with a beach club, a marina, and an outpost of its Manhattan Mediterranean restaurant on site. Small enough that the service should be personal, and the restaurant pedigree is the reason to look.
Best for: Food-led weekends, couples, harbor-side stays.
The Surf Lodge
The Surf Lodge is a bar and a music venue on Fort Pond that has rooms, and the rooms are secondary to the operation. The 2026 season leans harder into live bands than it has before, with St. Lucia, Matt Quinn of Mt. Joy, and Grace Bowers on the schedule alongside the usual DJs. If that's what you came for, staying on site is the best possible version of it. You walk twenty feet to your room at the end of the night.
The honest caveat: it is loud, it is expensive for what the rooms are, and the property is full of people who are not guests. Nobody should book this for a restful weekend.
Best for: The scene, and only the scene.
The Crow's Nest
A small restaurant-led property on Lake Montauk with a handful of rooms and one of the better dinners in town, eaten outside looking west over the water. The rooms are simple and the setting does the work.
Best for: Couples, food-first short stays, sunsets.
Ruschmeyer's
The camp-style option, set back near Fort Pond with cabin-feel rooms, a garden, lawn games, and the Electric Eel bar on site. Rooms range from standard queens up to suites sleeping five, so it works for groups splitting a booking.
The honest caveat: it's a social property with a bar attached, which means the same warning as the Surf Lodge applies at a lower volume.
Best for: Groups of friends, budget-conscious weekends, anyone who wants a garden rather than a lobby.
Solé East
Two properties under one operation, both near Lake Montauk, both renovated in recent years, with gardens and a pool and a restaurant. This is the reliable middle of the Montauk market: not new, not a scene, not oceanfront, and priced well below the beach properties.
Best for: Value, longer stays, travelers who plan to be out all day anyway.
Hero Beach Club
A reworked motel walkable to both the town center and the beach, with a seasonal pool, spa services, and free parking, which in Montauk is not nothing. The rooms are modest and the location is the product.
Best for: Short stays, walkability, people who intend to drink at dinner.
Check rates and availability—>
Which Montauk hotel is right for you
Book Gurney's if you want one property that handles the whole weekend, you're going in winter, or the ocean directly below the room is non-negotiable.
Book Montauk Yacht Club if you have children, a boat, or a group. It's the most facilities per dollar in Montauk and the calm harbor water is a real advantage with small kids.
Book Marram if you want to be on the ocean without resort pricing and you care about how the room looks. Pay up for beachfront or ocean view. The dune rooms face a parking lot.
Book the Surf Lodge if the nightlife is the reason you're coming. Book something else if it isn't.
Book Solé East or Hero Beach Club if the hotel is a base rather than the trip, and you'd rather spend the difference on dinner.
Book Amagansett instead if you want walkable dinners, better shopping, and calmer beaches. Our Amagansett and Montauk comparison works through that properly, and the Amagansett guide covers where to stay and eat there. It's twenty minutes west and a meaningfully different trip.
Best time to visit Montauk and when to book
Late September and October are the best weeks of the year out here and the reason to plan around the shoulder. The ocean is still warm enough to swim, the light is extraordinary, the traffic disappears after Labor Day, and rates drop by a third or more. If you can go then, go then.
Late May and early June are the other window. Everything has reopened, the crowds haven't arrived, and prices haven't peaked.
July and August are peak. Montauk is fully alive and fully expensive, the town is at capacity, and Friday afternoon traffic east from Manhattan is genuinely punishing. Take the LIRR instead if the trip is a weekend.
November through March is quiet, and Gurney's is the only property that really operates through it. Cold, empty beaches and a very different town. Worth doing once.
On booking: July and August weekends need four to five months, and the oceanfront rooms at the good properties go earlier than that. The shoulder season is usually available inside six weeks. Winter you can book on a Thursday for that Saturday.
On cost: roughly $400 to $700 a night in the shoulder at the mid-tier properties and $800 to $1,500 in peak at the oceanfront ones. Solé East, Hero Beach Club and Ruschmeyer's sit well below that. Gurney's and the Yacht Club sit at the top. Two-night minimums are standard in summer and three-night minimums are common on holiday weekends.
Getting there: about two and a half to three hours from Manhattan by car in normal traffic and considerably longer on a summer Friday. The LIRR runs to Montauk station and takes roughly three and a half hours, which is slower on paper and faster in practice in July. Once you're there you want a car, or a hotel that runs shuttles.
FAQs about hotels in Montauk
What is the best hotel in Montauk? Gurney's Montauk for a full-service oceanfront stay, and Montauk Yacht Club if you have a family, a boat, or a group. Marram is the best value of the properties actually on the ocean.
Where should I stay in Montauk with kids? Montauk Yacht Club, for the calm harbor water, the family pool, and the space. Marram works too if you want the ocean, and the fire pits and s'mores are a genuine hit with children.
Is the Surf Lodge a good place to stay? Only if you want the party. It's a music venue and bar with rooms attached, and it's loud, busy, and full of non-guests. Book it deliberately or not at all.
How much do Montauk hotels cost? Roughly $400 to $700 a night in the shoulder season and $800 to $1,500 in July and August at the oceanfront properties. Solé East, Hero Beach Club and Ruschmeyer's run considerably less.
When is the best time to visit Montauk? Late September and October. The water is still warm, the crowds are gone after Labor Day, and rates fall substantially. Late May and early June are the other good window.
Is Montauk open in winter? Partly. Gurney's runs year round and a handful of restaurants stay open on weekends, but most of the town closes. It's a real experience if you want empty beaches and don't need much else.
How far in advance should I book Montauk? Four to five months for July and August weekends, and earlier for oceanfront rooms. Six weeks is usually enough in the shoulder season.
Should I stay in Montauk or Amagansett? Montauk for surf, nightlife, and dramatic coastline. Amagansett for walkable dinners, better shopping, and calmer beaches. Amagansett is the easier trip with young children.
Is there an ocean side and a harbor side? Yes, and it matters. The ocean side is surf and dunes. The harbor side around Lake Montauk and Star Island is calm water, boats, and sunsets. Pick before you book.